Latest News

What does a dingo do?  

Supress foxes and feral cats? You tell me. 

(Note: This article from the November issue of The Report (2026) has been updated by the author.)

By Dr Ben Allen 

Perhaps you’ve heard that dingoes can supress foxes and feral cats (or some other pest animal) or that poison baiting, trapping or shooting dingoes will lead to an increase in mid-level predators such as foxes and cats, which will then lead to a decrease in our precious native fauna. This idea is known as ‘mesopredator release’ or a ‘trophic cascade’ and their existence and relevance have been the subject of much debate throughout many years. What does the science say about it? 

Let’s explore a hypothetical example together to answer that question. Imagine that you’re a PhD student searching for evidence of a trophic cascade at a site that has dingoes, foxes, cats, koalas and reptiles. Because you don’t want to remove or kill dingoes yourself, you have to select a site where someone else is already doing these things. So, you select a site where no dingo control occurs in a national park characterised by an undisturbed eucalyptus forest habitat and you compare it to the adjacent plantation pine forest with cattle grazing underneath, where the manager told you that they have baited dingoes with poison for years. 

You’re broke and ‘on the clock’ to get your thesis finished so don’t have the time to monitor fauna at the site over multiple seasons and years; and your social life is important, too, so you only managed to complete one winter survey in the baited area followed by a second summer survey in the unbaited area six months later. 

What did you find? The relevant details and survey results are shown in the table below. 

Pine forest Eucalyptus forest 
Background  Poisoning, trapping and shooting Livestock grazing  Survey 1 (winter) results  Low numbers of dingoes High numbers of foxes and cats Low numbers of koalas Low numbers of reptiles Background  No poisoning, trapping and shooting No livestock grazing  Survey 2 (summer) results  High numbers of dingoes Low numbers of foxes and cats High numbers of koalas High numbers of reptiles 

Just like you expected, dingo numbers were high in the unbaited area, where cat and fox numbers were low and koala and reptile numbers were high. The opposite was true in the baited area. 

Dingoes can suppress populations of livestock and some native species (i.e. their prey), but there is no reliable evidence that dingoes suppress foxes or feral cats (i.e. their competitors).

Eureka! You’ve found evidence ‘consistent with’ the view that dingoes supress foxes and cats and indirectly protect threatened fauna. You publish your results and promote it through the media. Your social media fans shower down ‘Likes’ for months and you get a promotion. Your friends do the same type of studies, find the same type of results, and you all win a prestigious award for it. Documentaries are made about it; the findings make their way into textbooks, and the ideas are taught as fact in ecology degrees in universities around the world. 

Case closed, right? 

But look a little closer; think a bit deeper and ask yourself what else might explain these results. 

Attention readers: Pause here, reflect on the information in the table and see if you can come up with some alternative explanations to explain these results before you read further. 

Maybe koala numbers were lower in the baited area because it was a pine plantation, and koalas don’t eat or live in pine trees like they do the eucalyptus trees in the unbaited area. 

Maybe reptiles were higher in the unbaited area because you did your survey there in summer, and reptiles hibernate in winter when you surveyed the baited area. 

Maybe threatened fauna numbers were lower in the baited area because it’s a simplified ecosystem of pine trees and cattle, and fauna do better in complex ecosystems absent of overgrazing. 

And how do you know that foxes or cats were ‘released’ or increased in number if you only surveyed the site once? Wouldn’t you need at least two surveys to know if their numbers went from A to B with time? 

And how do you know that dingoes even decreased (i.e. the prerequisite for foxes and cats to increase) following baiting in the first place if you relied on the manager’s word and didn’t even measure it? How intensive was the baiting, and were the baits even eaten by dingoes? Without confirming this aren’t you just guessing or assuming that all of this has anything to do with dingoes or dingo control? 

By now it should be apparent to any sensible person that multiple, plausible and much more likely alternative explanations exist for the initial observation that fewer koalas and reptiles exist in dingo-baited areas. The careful reader will also notice that many of these have nothing whatsoever to do with dingoes. 

By now you might also be thinking that the hypothetical example given above has been exaggerated for dramatic effect to illustrate the point. I wish this were true, but it’s not. There is no study that compares a pine plantation to a national park, but the scientific literature is systemically riddled with studies that use identical methods to the one I’ve just described. 

Adding to earlier reviews1 on the subject, Geoff Castle and colleagues recently tabulated all these (and more) problems with the available studies2 and found that 83 per cent of them suffer from experimental design issues that prevent them from determining dingoes’ roles in supressing foxes and cats. Only eight studies have ever been done in a way that could definitively determine dingoes’ suppressive effects on mesopredators, and all eight of them consistently demonstrated that dingoes do not supress mesopredators. 

Summarising 15 different myths, furphies and red herrings about dingo ecology and management3, I recently wrote “that lethal dingo control causes mesopredator release is a demonstrable myth” given that “not a single study (no, not one) has ever measured a numerical increase of foxes or cats in response to a measured decrease in dingoes”. 

Does this mean that dingoes are not an important player in Australian ecosystems? Of course not. They are important for many reasons, but ‘their suppressive effects on foxes and cats’ are not one of them. 

Instead, this should be a cautionary reminder to approach scientific claims – even widespread and well-accepted ones – with scepticism, because what you find depends a lot on how you look. 

Returning to our initial question: What does the science say about it? Would you be confident in declaring that dingoes supress mesopredators if the type of data described in the table above was all you had? Me neither. 

Dingoes will eat whatever is available to them where they live, including prey ranging in size from insects to whales. Dingo prey can often include livestock, macropods, bandicoots, rabbits, rodents and reptiles.

References 

1Allen BL, Fleming PJS, Allen LR, Engeman RM, Ballard G, & Leung LK-P. (2013). As clear as mud: a critical review of evidence for the ecological roles of Australian dingoes. Biological Conservation, 159:158–174. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2012.12.004  

2Castle G, Kennedy MS, & Allen BL. (2023). Stuck in the mud: Persistent failure of ‘the science’ to provide reliable information on the ecological roles of Australian dingoes. Biological Conservation, 285:110234. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2023.110234  

3Allen BL. (2026). Myths, furphies and red herrings associated with dingo ecology and management. Ecological Management & Restoration, 27:e70055. https://doi.org/10.1111/emr.70055